Explore Ice Creams
- 19,516
- 12
- Item Reviews
- Customize
- All Rankings
Top 10 Best Ice Creams
Welcome to the Ice Cream Piki, the best place to decide between ice creams. Ice creams come in a variety of flavors. Pick tasty ice creams according to what you like best. This Piki makes use of more than 19,000 facts about 281 ice creams. Sort and filter these ice creams according to your preferences using the options on the left. Whether you're looking for ice creams for diabetics, ice creams for don't forget vanilla or something else entirely, we have you covered.
You are currently viewing the best ice creams. We stack everything according to PikiRank, which measures each item's performance for all users combined. If you're looking for a good bet, pick an item near the top.
Select Criteria
Reset Preferences
Recent Activity on Ice Creams
-
alaina
edited the Ice Cream Piki
03/14 at 4:52 PM (EDT)
Independent, Unbiased, Fact-Based Rankings
Selected Preferences Overall: Best
Espresso Chip (Edy's)
Chocolaty espresso chips fill this coffee flavor frozen dairy dessert.
-
Calories: 120 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Espresso Chip (Edy's) achieves 68% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 14 gms, Calories - 120 cal, Cholesterol - 10 gms
Espresso Chip (Edy's) achieves 68% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Coffee, Espresso
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Espresso Chip (Edy's) achieves 43% performance in this category.
Cherry Chocolate Cordial Ice Cream (Hershey's)
Black cherry ice cream with thick chocolate fudge, real black cherries and cherry filled chocolate hearts.
-
Calories: 220 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Cherry Chocolate Cordial Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 39% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 17 gms, Calories - 220 cal, Cholesterol - 45 gms
Cherry Chocolate Cordial Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 52% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Cherry, Chocolate
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Cherry Chocolate Cordial Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 46% performance in this category.
Muddy Sneakers Ice Cream (Hershey's)
Premium chocolate caramel peanut candies and milk chocolate flakes in premium white chocolate ice cream with a caramel fudge ripple.
-
Calories: 140 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Muddy Sneakers Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 62% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 13 gms, Calories - 140 cal, Cholesterol - 35 gms
Muddy Sneakers Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 56% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Caramel, Chocolate, White Chocolate
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Muddy Sneakers Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 78% performance in this category.
Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster (Hershey's)
Caramel ice cream loaded with delicious cookies and cream cheesecake chunks and a chocolate wafe cookie swirl.
-
Calories: 220 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster (Hershey's) achieves 39% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 19 gms, Calories - 220 cal, Cholesterol - 50 gms
Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster (Hershey's) achieves 59% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Caramel, Cheesecake, Chocolate
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster (Hershey's) achieves 100% performance in this category.
Superman Ice Cream (Hershey's)
Premium three fruity flavors swirled together: Strawberry, Banana, and Blue Moon.
-
Calories: 140 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Superman Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 62% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 14 gms, Calories - 140 cal, Cholesterol - 30 gms
Superman Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 60% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Banana
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Superman Ice Cream (Hershey's) achieves 5% performance in this category.
Fudge Tracks (Edy's)
We've mixed vanilla light ice cream with fudge and amazing chunks of real miniature peanut butter cups to create this peanut buttery taste sensation with 50% less fat and 30% fewer calories than regular ice cream. Especially for peanut butter lovers!
-
Calories: 120 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Fudge Tracks (Edy's) achieves 68% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 13 gms, Calories - 120 cal, Cholesterol - 20 gms
Fudge Tracks (Edy's) achieves 71% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Vanilla
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Fudge Tracks (Edy's) achieves 28% performance in this category.
Spumoni (Edy's)
Three flavors in one! Chocolate, spumoni with mixed fruit pieces and almonds and pistachio flavors.
-
Calories: 120 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Spumoni (Edy's) achieves 68% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 14 gms, Calories - 120 cal, Cholesterol - 15 gms
Spumoni (Edy's) achieves 70% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Chocolate, Pistachio
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Spumoni (Edy's) achieves 56% performance in this category.
Chocolate Red. Fat/No Sugar Added (Hershey's)
Reduced fat chocolate ice cream with NutraSweet®.
-
Calories: 110 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Chocolate Red. Fat/No Sugar Added (Hershey's) achieves 71% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 5 gms, Calories - 110 cal, Cholesterol - 20 gms
Chocolate Red. Fat/No Sugar Added (Hershey's) achieves 58% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Chocolate
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Chocolate Red. Fat/No Sugar Added (Hershey's) achieves 34% performance in this category.
No Sugar Added Moose Tracks (Hershey's)
Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with peanut butter cup candy bars swirled in a flood of Denali® Moose Tracks® fudge without the added sugar.
-
Calories: 170 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, No Sugar Added Moose Tracks (Hershey's) achieves 53% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 5 gms, Calories - 170 cal, Cholesterol - 20 gms
No Sugar Added Moose Tracks (Hershey's) achieves 53% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Vanilla
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, No Sugar Added Moose Tracks (Hershey's) achieves 34% performance in this category.
Mint Cookie Crunch (Edy's)
Voted top flavor by ice cream lovers, this mint light ice cream with chocolate sandwich cookie pieces is tops. And it's 50% less fat and 30% fewer calories than regular ice cream.
-
Calories: 120 cal
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams prefer lower values for calories, Mint Cookie Crunch (Edy's) achieves 68% performance in this category.
-
Nutrition: Sugars - 13 gms, Calories - 120 cal, Cholesterol - 20 gms
Mint Cookie Crunch (Edy's) achieves 71% performance for nutrition.
-
Flavors: Chocolate, Mint
Given that users looking for the best overall ice creams have a preference for vanilla, chocolate and rum and prefer a larger number of flavors options, Mint Cookie Crunch (Edy's) achieves 56% performance in this category.